Technique Tip: A Plucking Primer

I teach a lot.
Author:
Publish date:
Image placeholder title

I TEACH A LOT. AMONG THE MANY BENEFITS, BOTH practical and otherwise, is that teaching is a constant reminder of what it’s like to be in the early stages of getting to know the bass. The only other good shortcut I know of is to intentionally play the bass in the “reverse-handed” way, e.g., if you play right-handed, flip it over and pluck with your left hand. Try it, and you’ll feel like an instant rookie.

As all of us can sympathize, one of the big initial hurdles for rank beginners is figuring out how to coordinate the plucking and fretting hands. At the outset, I try to tackle each separately, caring less about shabby technique in one hand if a student is still trying to get their fingers (and minds) around an exercise in the other. At some point, though, the time arrives to coordinate the hands and get down to the business of bass playing. I relish this period, because I have the blessed opportunity to impart all my brilliant insight and forever influence the way they play. Oh, the power!

But rank beginners are not the focus of this piece. Instead, I’d like to talk to those of us who have been at this thing for a while. I’ve taught many non-beginners, some with decades of experience under their belt, and here’s one nearly universal trait they have in common: an underestimation of how much alteration in tone is available in the plucking hand. Whether it’s playing with your fingertips, a pick, palm-muting, slapping, or doing any of the above with an added awareness of where on the string your playing, there’s more sonic variety available via the plucking hand than most any EQ. Get a hand-le (ha!) on this, and at the very least you’ll be less apt to reach immediately for the amp when you’re not digging your tone.

HOW YOU PLUCK

Let’s focus on all the interesting sound available from your hand— we’ll get to position relative to the bass in a bit. There are dozens of ways to address the string to make it vibrate, and when you compound that by the variety of hands themselves, there are millions of tones out there. In my highly subjective order of popularity, here’s a run-down of plucking-hand techniques to explore:

The alternating fingertip pluck. This is the standard-issue fingerstyle technique. The index and middle fingers of the plucking hand brush past the string, ideally with a fairly consistent 1–2 alternation to maximize efficiency. If you aspire to play fingerstyle, you must master this technique. It produces round and even tone, assuming you’ve trimmed your fingernails—if not, that’s something else entirely. It also is well suited for string crossing and speed.

Slap. Whether you love it, hate it, or merely find it culturally unfashionable, slap-and-pop is one the instrument’s most distinctive abilities. It maximizes percussive potential, allowing a player to behave as much like a drummer as a melodic instrumentalist. The prevailing approach involves using the bony part of the thumb, near the knuckle, to slap one of the two or three lower strings, while the index finger pops one of the higher strings with an aggressive snap. I prefer orienting the thumb so that it’s essentially parallel to the strings, rather than perpindular-ish, à la Flea. More advanced approaches elaborate upon the technique to unveil a huge palette of sound.

Pick. Playing with a pick is a weirdly polarizing thing, for no good reason. I’ve even talked to non-musicians with an odd prejudice against bass players who use one. Instead of arguing, I usually just feel impressed that they even know what a bass is. Anyway, if you’re in the anti-pick faction, it’s time to get hip. Sure, you can just pump out solid-and-simple eighth-notes—and that’s totally cool—but there is so much more available. Whether it’s the unbeatably even and sharp attack, the locomotive funk when combined with judicious muting, or the abrasive and singular sounds that emerge when you use the pick at different angles, it’s time to put the pick prejudice behind us.

Palm-muting and thumb-plucking. If you’re looking for big bottom end and quick decay, this is your go-to technique. The pinkie side of the palm is gently laid across the strings near the bridge, while the thumb handles plucking duties. It’s an excellent way to mimic the note envelope of an acoustic bass or reduce an instrument’s high-frequency response for pillowy bass response in R&B, reggae, and other low-frequency-dependent styles. Varying the palm’s pressure on the strings allows precise control over your sustain. One limitation: With only the thumb doing the plucking, it can be hard to play fast.

Palm-muting (or not) and plucking with more than just the thumb. This technique evolves the thumb-only approach to include one or more of the other plucking-hand fingers. It may or may not include a palm-mute, but it does orient the hand in a similar fashion. This addresses the speed disadvantages of using the thumb alone, and can have a huge impact on efficiency and speed. Whether it’s the sophisticated approach of someone like Gary Willis or the no-less-advanced flamenco-esque style of Matthew Garrison or Abe Laboriel, this technique may be difficult to master, but is potentially one of the most effective—it combines the round and fleshy attack of traditional fingerstyle while capitalizing on the fact that our hands have more than two fingers.

There are many more options, to be sure, but these are the most common. Feel free to disabuse me of this notion on Bass Player’s Facebook page.

LOCATION, LOCATION, LOCATION

In parallel to all this discussion of plucking-hand technique, there must also be careful consideration of exactly where on the bass you’re doing your plucking, slapping, muting, picking, etc. To begin to discover the huge sonic variety available by attentive positioning, try plucking a string with just one finger, all along its length between the bridge and the neck’s highest fret. You’ll notice that the closer you are to the bridge, the more midrange-y and percussive the attack. Moving your finger nearer to the neck reveals an increasingly syrupy sound that reaches full rubber-band booty as you pluck close to or directly over the neck’s end. Essentially, by plucking in different positions, you’re altering the overtone characteristics of the string, resulting in a gradient of timbres that change substantially as the hand travels to and fro. It is truly like a built-in EQ for the bass, as this alteration of a string’s overtones dramatically affects its frequency response.

At this point, you have probably also noticed how different a string feels near the bridge versus near the neck. Near the bridge, it feels tight and pluck-resistant; as you move toward the neck it’s more pliant and flexible. This quality can dramatically alter plucking technique as the string’s perceived tension demands more or less strength to get it going.

Whether all of the above is old news to you, or if it helps to catalyze some exploration of your own, there’s no doubt that the plucking hand is under-recognized as a tone-shaping asset. Rather than a utilitarian necessity to make a string vibrate, plucking-hand technique is an essential expressive tool.

Related

bp1309_TechTip-1

Technique Tip : Anchors Away

Teaching beginners always forces me to confront my so-called comfort zone. It happens to all of us: Once we feel like we’re beyond beginner status, we tend to take the fundamental stuff for granted. I was teaching the student about fingerstyle pluckinghand technique. I reinforced the alternating-finger concept, pointing out the importance of a solid thumb-anchor. I had the student pluck a few notes with his thumb free-floating, and then with the thumb anchored on the pickup (Fig. 1). The immediate difference in strength and control is obvious.

Image placeholder title

Technique Tip Fingertip Talk

IT WOULD SEEM THAT WITH JUST FIVE fingers and 4-6 strings (oh, alright, sometimes more), there’d be a relatively short list of potential right-hand techniques. But if there’s one thing my incessant Lockup on MSNBC habit has taught me, necessity breeds invention. Take the Funk Brother himself, James Jamerson. Everyone knows that he played all that phenomenally dexterous stuff with just one finger, “the Hook,” as it came to be known. We’ve all wondered how he pulled it off, but sitting in on the Motown mastertape listening session for this month’s cover story made this question more urgent than ever. With Jamerson’s tracks soloed, the near physical impossibility of some lines was striking. So, capitalizing on the rare opportunity, I asked fellow listener James Jamerson Jr. Sure enough, James confirmed what I long thought: On uptempo tunes, Jamerson Sr. would occasionally pluck with both sides of the Hook—fingerpad and fingernail, like in Figs. 1 and 2. It was a rare occurrence, but ap

0.00BP0210_woodtip_1_nr

Technique Tip Tasty Chords

UNLESS YOU’RE A SOLO BASSIST, YOU probably spend most of your time playing single-note lines. Sure, there’s the occasional delicious double-stop, but the more dense chordal content is generally left to your piano- and guitar-playing bandmates. Being strong, simple, and supportive is pretty much the gig. That said, I’ve stumbled on a pair of chord shapes that are easy to grab, are harmonically supportive, and have a rich and ethereal quality that works well in certain contexts, especially trios. Figure 1 shows the major, add9 shape, which works well over most major chords. From low to high, the intervals are 1, 5, 9, 10(3). Figure 2 shows the shape’s minor alternative. Its intervals, in order, are 1, 5, 9, b10(b3). I think the chord works particularly well arpeggiated. Figure 3 shows a plucking-hand fingering that uses each finger, classical-guitar style to cycle through each note individually. One final note: try this shape around and above the 12th fret. Any lower and it’ll hurt an

Technique Tip: New Tricks

GETTING BETTER AT BASS INVOLVES DIGESTING HUGE AMOUNTS OF new information, but it’s just as important to unlearn the bad stuff. Most of us picked up the bass without much initial guidance, and even though subsequent study can illuminate a better path, our individual approach is often cemented in those early moments of discovery. One extraordinarily common habit is to rest the forearm on the bass’s body, like in Fig. 1. I do it almost all the time if I’m playing with a traditional fingerstyle technique. Unfortunately, this is a perfect recipe for carpal tunnel syndrome, a painful condition that occurs when the passageway of bone and ligament at the base of the wrist compresses the median nerve. If that weren’t scary enough, the forearm muscles weakened position seems to rob the plucking hand of strength. Try the approach in Fig. 2, lifting the forearm off the bass. For me, it feels a little awkward, but I believe it’s technically a better option.

/uploadedImages/bassplayer/articles/bp1109_Wood_TechTip_Fig-1.jpg

Technique Tip: Poor Patterns

THERE ARE A FEW REASONS LYRICAL SOLOING SEEMS to come easier to horn players than bassists. First, by default, horn players spend a lot of their musical time playing melodies, thus burning melodicism deep into their musical DNA. Second, and perhaps more important, the saxophone is nowhere near as pattern-based as the bass. There’s something about the bass’s frets, dots, and strings that makes the fingerboard look like a big checkerboard to our pattern-craving cerebral cortex: Instead of allowing the deeper concerns of harmony and melody dictate our lines, the fingerboard’s visual and digital patterns easily seduce us, corrupting our note choices. One way around this is to seek opportunities to break out of our habitual, pattern-oriented playing by forcing our left hand to confront familiar sounds in unfamiliar ways. The most common major scale shape starts on the 2nd finger (Fig. 1). Try starting the scale on your 1st, 3rd, and 4th fingers, too. Since these shapes may be